¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ¼°ÆäÓ°ÏìÒòËØ¡ª¡ª¶ÔÔ²Ã÷Ô°ºþµ×ÆÌĤʼþµÄ·´Ë¼
[ÈÕÆÚ£º2008-05-15] À´Ô´£º¡¶¹æ»®Ê¦¡·2005(11) ×÷ÕߣºÎâÈËΤ Ñî¼Ì÷
·¢±íÆÀÂÛ(0)
´òÓ¡
Õª¡¡Òª£º¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¿É·ÖΪ»ý¼«²ÎÓë¡¢Ïû¼«²ÎÓë¡¢²»²ÎÓëÈýÖÖÑ¡Ôñ·½Ê½¡£¹«ÖÚ¸öÌå²ÎÓë
³ÇÊй滮µÄÐÐΪÊܵ½¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓڹ滮ʼþµÄÃô¸ÐÐÔ¡¢¹æ»®ÏîÄ¿Ìæ´úÆ·µÄ¿ÉÇó³Ì¶È¡¢¹æ»®¾ö²ßµÄ¸Ä½ø¶ÔÓÚ¹«Öڵı߼ÊЧÓõÄÓ°Ïì¡¢¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆÚµÈËÄ·½ÃæÒòËصÄÓ°Ïì¡£Ìá¸ßÎÒ¹ú³ÇÊй滮ÖеĹ«ÖÚ²ÎÓë³Ì¶ÈÓ¦µ±´ÓÍêÉÆ·¨ÖÆÌåϵ¡¢È·Á¢ÐÎʽ±£ÕÏÄÚÈÝ¡¢
ÅàÓý¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄÖҳϸÐÈý¸ö·½ÃæÈëÊÖ¡£
¹Ø¼ü×Ö£º¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓ룻³ÇÊй滮£»ÐÐΪѡÔñ
The behavioral Selection of Public Participation in Planning and Its Influencing Factors¡ª Reflection on the Spreading of Plastic Film at the Lake Bottoms of Yuan-Ming Yuan Imperial Garden/WU Renwei,Yang Jimei
[Abstract] Public participation can be classified as active,passive and no participation.The individual behavioral decision is affected by the sensitivity of the planning event,the extent of obtainability of the planned project substitute, the marginal utility on the public by the improvement in planning decision,and the effect expectation of the public in participation in the planning,etc.To increase the extent of public participation in city planning in China,it is advisable to start from the three aspects of perfecting the legal system,establishing the content of formal guarantee and foster the awareness of faithfulness in public participation.
[Key words] public participation,Urban planning,behavioral selection
¡¡¡¡×Ô2005Äê3ÔÂ28ÈÕ¡¶ÈËÃñÈÕ±¨¡·Ê×´ÎÅû¶¡°Ô²Ã÷Ô°ºþµ×ÆÌÉè·ÀÉøĤÔâר¼ÒÖÊÒÉ¡±ÒÔÀ´£¬¡°Ô²Ã÷԰ʼþ¡±ÒýÆðÁ˹úÄÚ¸÷½çµÄ¹ã·º¹Ø×¢£¬Ã¬Í·»ù±¾É϶¼Ö¸ÏòÁ˹ÙÔ±ÎÊÔð¡¢¹ÜÀíÌåÖÆ£¬ÒÔ¼°¶Ô·¨ÖƼලµÄËßÇó¡£È»¶ø£¬»ØËÝʼþµÄÆðÒò¡ª¶ÔÕâÑùÒ»¸öʱ¼ä³¤´ïÁ½ÄêÖ®¾ÃµÄÆÆ»µ¹¤³ÌµÄ×·¾¿£¬¾¹È»Ê¼ÓÚһλÆÕͨµÄ¹«ÖÚ¡£Ò»·½Ã棬ÕâÒ»ÏÖÏó±¾ÉíÌåÏÖÁËÎÒ¹ú¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÁ¦Á¿£»µ«ÁíÒ»·½Ã棬¡°Á½ÄꡱÕâһʱ¼ä¸ÅÄîµÄ±³ºóÒ²ÌåÏÖÁËÎÒ¹ú¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®ÖƶȵÄÖͺó¡£Òò´Ë£¬ÎÒÃÇÔÚÖÊÒÉÎÒ¹ú·¨ÖƼලÌåϵµÄͬʱ£¬Ò²Ó¦¸Ã·´Ë¼Ôڹ滮¿ª·¢¹ý³ÌÖй«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ¶¯Á¦ÓëÖÆÔ¼ÒòËØ¡£ÃÀ¹úµÄ¾¼Ãѧ¼Ò°¢¶û²®ÌØ¡¤O¡¤ºÕÏ£Âü(Albert¡¤O¡¤Hirschman)ÓÚ1960ÄêÌá³öÁË¡°Í˳ö¡ªºôÓõ¡±ÀíÂÛ£¬´ÓÃñÖ÷¹ÜÀíµÄ½Ç¶È̽ÌÖÁ˸öÌåÔÚ×éÖ¯¼¨Ð§ÖеÄÐÐΪ¾ö²ß¼°ÆäÓ°ÏìÒòËØ£¬²¢Îª¹æ»®ÀíÂÛ½çÌṩÁËÑо¿¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ·ÖÎö¹¤¾ß¡£
1¡¢¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ
¡¡¡¡¸ù¾ÝºÕÏ£ÂüµÄÀíÂÛ£¬¡°Í˳ö¡±¾ÍÊÇÖ¸¡°Ïû·ÑÕß²»ÔÙ¹ºÂòÆóÒµµÄ²úÆ·»òÕßijЩ»áÔ±Í˳ö×éÖ¯¡±¡£¡°ºôÓõ¡±ÔòÊÇÖ¸¡°»áԱΪÐÞÕýÆóÒµ»ò×éÖ¯µÄ¹ßÀý¡¢Õþ²ß»ò²ú³öËù×÷µÄÖÖÖÖ³¢ÊÔ»òŬÁ¦¡£µ±ÆóÒµµÄ²úÆ·»ò×éÖ¯µÄ·þÎñÄÑÒÔÁîÈËÂúÒâʱ£¬ÈκÎÊÔͼ¸Ä±äÕâÖÖ×´¿ö¶ø²»ÊÇÌÓÒݵĴëÊ©£¬¶¼·ûºÏºôÓõµÄ»ù±¾¶¨Ò塱¡£
¡¡¡¡´Ó¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ¿´£¬ÔÚÕþ¸®»òÕ߹滮¾ö²ßÕßÌṩ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÍâ»·¾³µÄ¼ÙÉèÇ°ÌáÏ£¬¹«ÖÚƾ½è¸öÌåÀíÐÔÅжϣ¬°´ÕÕ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÉîdz³Ì¶ÈÖ÷ÒªÓÐÈýÖÖ²ÎÓëÑ¡Ôñ·½Ê½£ºÆäÒ»ÊÇ»ý¼«²ÎÓë(»ò³ÆÕæʵ²ÎÓë)£¬¼´Äܹ»½«¸öÈ˵ÄÕæʵÏë·¨¼°Ê±¡¢ÓÐЧµØÌṩ¸ø¹æ»®¾ö²ßÕߣ¬²¢»ý¼«¹Ø×¢Õû¸ö¹æ»®µÄʵʩ¹ý³ÌºÍʵʩ½á¹û£»Æä¶þÊÇÏû¼«²ÎÓë(»ò³ÆÐé¼Ù²ÎÓë)£¬¼´ºÜÉÙ±í´ï¸öÈËÒâ¼û£¬»òÕß²»±í´ï¸öÈ˵ÄÕæʵÒâ¼û£»ÆäÈýÊDz»²ÎÓ룬ÕâÊÇÒ»ÖÖ¼«¶ËµÄÇé¿ö£¬¼´¸ù±¾²»ÏàÐÅ»òÕß²»Ô¸Òâ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ¾ö²ß¹ý³Ì¡£°´ÕÕ¡°Í˳ö¡ªºôÓõ¡±ÀíÂÛ£¬Ç°Á½ÖÖ²ÎÓ뷽ʽ¶¼¿ÉÒÔÊÓΪ¡°ºôÓõ¡±µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ£¬¶ø×îºóÒ»ÖÖ£¬ÏÔÈ»ÊÇÒ»ÖÖ¡°Í˳ö¡±µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ¡£
2¡¢¹«ÖÚÐÐΪѡÔñµÄÓ°ÏìÒòËØ
¡¡¡¡×÷Ϊ¾¼Ã¡¢ÀíÐÔµÄÈË£¬³ýÁËÉç»áµÀµÂµÄ·ÇÕý¹æÔ¼ÊøÖ®Í⣬¹«ÖÚ¸öÌåµÄÐÐΪÅжÏÖ÷Òª»¹ÊÇ»ùÓÚ¶Ô¸öÌåËù»ñµÃµÄ¾¼ÃÀû±×µÄȨºâ¡£Òò´Ë£¬´Ó¹«ÖڵĽǶÈÉóÊÓ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÎÊÌ⣬Æä¸öÌåµÄÐÐΪ¾ö²ßÖ÷ÒªÊܵ½ÒÔÏÂËÄ·½ÃæÒòËصÄÓ°Ïì¡£
2.1 ¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓڹ滮ʼþµÄÃô¸ÐÐÔ
¡¡¡¡¾Í³ÇÊй滮Ìá¼°µÄ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¶øÑÔ£¬¡°¹«ÖÚ¡±ÊÇÒ»¸ö·ºÖ¸µÄ¸ÅÄ¼´º¸ÇÁ˳ýµØ·½Õþ¸®¡¢¹æ»®»ú¹¹¡¢¹æ»®Ê¦Ö®ÍâµÄËùÓÐÆäËûÀûÒæÏà¹ØÕß(stakeholder)¡£È»¶øÓÉÓÚÊܵ½ÄêÁä¡¢ÐÔ¸ñ¡¢ÊܽÌÓý³Ì¶È¡¢Ö°Òµ¡¢Éç»áµØλµÈÒòËØÓ°Ï죬²»Í¬µÄ¹«ÖÚ¸öÌå¶ÔÓÚ³ÇÊй滮¾ö²ßµÄ¸ÐÖªÄÜÁ¦Óëʶ±ðÄÜÁ¦Ò²´æÔÚמ޴óµÄ²îÒ죬´Ó¾¼ÃѧµÄ½Ç¶È½²£¬¿ÉÒÔ½«Æä³ÆΪ¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓÚ³ÇÊй滮¾ö²ßµÄÃô¸ÐÐÔ£¬»òÕ߹滮¾ö²ßµ¯ÐÔ¡£
¡¡¡¡½øÒ»²½µØ½²£¬Ôڹ滮ÏîÄ¿Éæ¼°µ½¹«ÖÚÀûÒæµÄʱºò£¬¾ö²ßÃô¸ÐÐԸߵĹ«ÖÚ¸öÌåÍùÍùÄܹ»×îÏȸÐÊܵ½¹æ»®ÖдæÔÚµÄÏà¹ØÎÊÌâ¡£°´ÕÕ¡°Í˳ö¡ªºôÓõ¡±ÀíÂÛ£¬Õⲿ·ÖÈËÊ×ÏȻῼÂDzÉÈ¡¡°Í˳ö¡±µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ¡£¾Í¹æ»®²ÎÓë¶øÑÔ£¬¹«ÖÚΩһµÄÍ˳ö·½Ê½Ö»Êǹ«ÖÚµ¥·½Ãæ·ÅÆú²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄȨÀû£¬¶ø¶ÔÓڹ滮¾ö²ßÕß¼°¹æ»®ÏîÄ¿±¾Éí²¢ÎÞÓ°Ï죬¼È²»Äܸıä¹æ»®¾ö²ßµÄÄÚÈÝ£¬Ò²²»ÄÜÌá¸ß¸öÌåµÄʵ¼ÊЧÒ棬ËùÒÔÍ˳öµÄÐÐΪ²¢²»¿ÉÑ¡¡£ÔÚÍ˳öÎÞЧµÄÇé¿öÏ£¬¹«ÖÚΩÓÐÑ¡ÔñºôÓõ(²ÎÓë¹æ»®)µÄ·½Ê½¡£´Ëʱ£¬¹«ÖڵĹ滮¾ö²ßÃô¸ÐÐÔÓ빫ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÉî¶È³ÉÕý±È¡£¾ö²ßÃô¸ÐÐԸߵĹ«ÖھͻáÑ¡Ôñ»ý¼«²ÎÓë¹æ»®£¬Á¦Çó¸ÄÉƹ滮ÄÚÈÝ£¬Ó°Ïì¹æ»®¾ö²ß¡£¶ø¹æ»®¾ö²ßÃô¸ÐÐԵ͵Ĺ«ÖÚ¸öÌ壬һ·½Ãæ¿ÉÄÜÉÐûÓÐÒâʶµ½ÎÊÌâµÄ´æÔÚ£»ÁíÒ»·½Ã棬¼´Ê¹¸ÐÊܵ½¹æ»®ÏîÄ¿¿ÉÄÜ´æÔÚijЩÎÊÌ⣬µ«Ò²¿ÉÄܳöÓÚ¡°´î±ã³µ¡±(Free Rider)µÄÐÄÀí£¬¶ø±£³Ö³ÁĬ£¬Ö±µ½ÎÊÌâÑÏÖص½Ò»¶¨³Ì¶È£¬³¬³öÆäËùÄÜÈÌÊܵij̶ȲŻáÑ¡Ôñ»ý¼«ºôÓõµÄÐÐΪ·½Ê½¡£
¡¡¡¡ÒÔ¡°Ô²Ã÷԰ʼþ¡±ÎªÀý¡£µÚһλ¹«¿ªÖÊÒÉÔ²Ã÷Ô°Õû¸Ä¹¤³ÌµÄר¼ÒÕÅÕý´º£¬ÊÇÀ¼ÖÝ´óѧÉúÃü¿ÆѧԺ½ÌÊÚ£¬ÕýÊÇÓÉÓÚËû³¤ÆÚ´ÓÊÂÉú̬ѧÑо¿²¢ÖÓ°®Öйú¹ÅµäÔ°ÁÖ£¬Ãô¸Ð¶È½Ï¸ß£¬²ÅÄܹ»Òâʶµ½ÎÊÌâµÄ´æÔÚ£¬²¢Ö÷¶¯×÷Ϊ£¬½«Õâһʼþ×·²éµ½µ×¡£ÎÞ¶ÀÓÐż£¬ÔÚ2001Äê10ÔÂÖøÃûµÄ¡°×Ͻðɽ¹Û¾°Ì¨·ç²¨¡±ÖУ¬Ò²ÊÇÊ×ÏÈÓɶ«ÄÏ´óѧµÄÁ½Ãû·¨ÂÉϵ½ÌʦÌá³öÖÊÒɵġ£Òò´Ë£¬¹«ÖÚ¸öÌåµÄ²îÒìÐÔÓ°Ï칫ÖڼලµÄʼþÃô¸Ð¶È£¬´Ó¶ø½øÒ»²½Ó°ÏìÆä²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ¡£
2.2 ¹æ»®ÏîÄ¿Ìæ´úÆ·µÄ¿ÉÇó³Ì¶È
¡¡¡¡´Ó¾¼ÃѧµÄ½Ç¶È½²£¬Èç¹ûÌæ´úÆ·ÍÙÊֿɵ㬼´Ìæ´úÆ·µÄËÑÑ°³É±¾ºÍ½»Ò׳ɱ¾×ã¹»µÍ£¬ÄÇô¹«ÖÚ¸öÌå¾Í²»»áÇáÒײÉÈ¡¡°ºôÓõ¡±µÄ·½Ê½¡£·´Ö®£¬Èç¹ûÌæ´úÆ·³É±¾ºÜ¸ß£¬Ôò¹«ÖÚºôÓõµÄÇãÏò¾ÍԽǿÁÒ¡£
¡¡¡¡Ïà¶ÔÓÚÊг¡ÉÏÒ»°ãµÄÁ÷ͨÉÌÆ·¶øÑÔ£¬¹æ»®ÏîÄ¿±¾ÉíÌØÓеļ¼Êõº¬Á¿Ê¹µÃÆäÌæ´úÆ·µÄ½»Ò׳ɱ¾ºÜ¸ß£¬Í¬Ê±ÆäÐÐÕþ±³¾°ºÍ×÷Ó÷¶Î§µÄµØÓòÐÔÒ²Ôö¼ÓÁ˹«ÖÚµÄÍ˳ö³É±¾¡£Ò²¾ÍÊÇ˵£¬¹«ÖÚ¸öÌåͨ¹ýǨ¾Ó¡¢ÒÆÃñµÈ·½Ê½ÍêÈ«Í˳ö¹æ»®×÷Ó÷¶Î§µÄ½»Ò׳ɱ¾(Í˳ö³É±¾)Ô¶Ô¶¸ßÓڸĽøÏÖÓй滮ÄÚÈݵĽ»Ò׳ɱ¾(ºôÓõ³É±¾)¡£Òò´Ë£¬´ÓÌæ´úÆ·µÄ½Ç¶È¶øÑÔ£¬¹«ÖÚ¸öÌåÔò¸üÔ¸ÒâÑ¡Ôñ(»òÕß²»µÃ²»Ñ¡Ôñ)»ý¼«²ÎÓë¹æ»®£¬Í¨¹ýÌá³öºÏÀí»¯½¨ÒéÁ¦Çó¸Ä½øÏÖÓй滮¡£
¡¡¡¡µ«ÊÇ£¬Ò²ÕýÊÇÒòΪ¸ß¶îÌæ´ú³É±¾µÄÊø¸¿£¬¡°ºôÓõ¡±ÍùÍù³ÉΪ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®Î©Ò»µÄÑ¡Ôñ·½Ê½¡£Ò»µ©¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄȨÁ¦±»°þ¶á£¬»òÕß¹«ÖÚµÄÒâ¼ûûÓÐÔڹ滮ʵʩÖеÃÒÔÌåÏÖ£¬ÄÇô·¨ÂɾͳÉΪ¹«ÖÚº´ÎÀ¸öÌåÀûÒæµÄ±ØÒªÊֶκÍ;¾¶¡£ÕâÒ²ÊǺôÓõµÄÒ»ÖÖ±íÏÖÐÎʽ£¬¼´Í¨¹ýµÚÈý·½(·¨ÂÉ)µÄ½éÈëÒýÆð¹æ»®¾ö²ßÕßµÄÖØÊÓ£¬Í¨¹ýÇ¿ÖÆÐÔÊÖ¶ÎÒªÇóÆä¶Ô¹æ»®´æÔÚµÄÎÊÌâÓèÒÔ»ØÓ¦¡£
¡¡¡¡ÒŲúÂÃÓεز»Í¬ÓÚÒ»°ã·ç¾°Çø£¬Æä×ÊÔ´±¾ÌåÔ̺¬×ŷḻµÄÀúÊ·ÎÄ»¯¼ÛÖµ£¬ÊÇÎÞ·¨¸´ÖƺͷÂðµÄ£¬ÆäϡȱÐÔºÍΩһÐÔµ¼Ö¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÒŲúÂÃÓεصĿª·¢¸üΪ¹Ø×¢¡£Ô²Ã÷Ô°¶ÔÓÚÊÀÈËÀ´ËµÊÇÎ޼۵ģ¬Ò²ÊDz»´æÔÚÌæ´ú²úÆ·µÄ£¬Ò»µ©Ôâµ½ÆÆ»µ£¬ÆäËðʧ½«ÄÑÒÔÓýðÇ®À´²¹³¥¡£¡°Ô²Ã÷԰ʼþ¡±Ö®ËùÒÔÒýÆð¹«ÖÚÈç´Ë¹ã·ºµÄ¹Ø×¢£¬ÆäÒŲú¼ÛÖµµÄ²»¿ÉÌæ´úÐÔÊÇÖ÷ÒªÔÒòÖ®Ò»¡£¹«ÖÚ²»ÄÜÍ˳ö£¬ËùÒÔÑ¡ÔñºôÓõ£¬Æä±íÕ÷Ö®Ò»¾ÍÊÇÔ²Ã÷԰ʼþÌýÖ¤»áµÄ¾Ù°ì¡£
2.3 ¹æ»®¾ö²ßµÄ¸Ä½ø¶ÔÓÚ¹«Öڵı߼ÊЧÓõÄÓ°Ïì
¡¡¡¡¡°±ß¼ÊЧÓá±(Marginal Utility)ÊÇÖ¸µ±ËùÓÐÆäËûµÄÉÌÆ·µÄÏû·Ñˮƽ±£³Ö²»±äʱ£¬´Ó¶îÍâÒ»µ¥Î»ÉÌÆ·ÖÐËù»ñµÃ¶îÍâÂú×ã(¼´Ð§ÓÃ)¡£¶Ô¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®¶øÑÔ£¬¾ÍÊÇÖ¸ÔÚÆäËûÌõ¼þ²»±äµÄÇé¿öÏ£¬¹æ»®¾ö²ßÄÚÈݵĸĽøÄܹ»¸ø¹«ÖÚ¸öÌå´øÀ´µÄʵ¼ÊºÃ´¦¡£
¡¡¡¡³ÇÊй滮µÄ¹«¹²ÊôÐÔ¾ö¶¨Á˹滮¾ö²ßµÄ¸Ä½øºÍÍêÉÆÄܹ»Ê¹¹«ÖÚȺÌåÆÕ±éÊÜÒ棬µ«ÊÇÕë¶Ô²»Í¬µÄ¹«ÖÚ¸öÌ壬Æä±ß¼ÊЧÓÃÈ´ÊÇ´æÔÚ²îÒìµÄ£¬ÕâÖֱ߼ÊЧÓõIJîÒìÐÔÒ²Ó°ÏìÁ˹«ÖÚÔÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®¹ý³ÌÖеÄÐÐΪƫºÃ¡£ÒÔ³ÇÊÐסÇø¹æ»®ÎªÀý£¬Ð¡ÇøÄÚ²¿µÄ¸½ÊôÉèÊ©½¨Éè¡¢Â̵ء¢¶ùͯÓÎí¬ÉèÊ©µÈ¶ÔÓÚÓÐСº¢µÄס»§¶øÑÔÖÁ¹ØÖØÒª£¬¹ÊÔ¸ÒâÖ÷¶¯È¥²ÎÓë¹æ»®£»¶ø¶ÔÓÚµ¥Éíºº»òÕß¾³£³ö²îµÄÉÌÂÃס»§¶øÑÔ£¬±ß¼ÊЧÓÃÔòҪСµÃ¶à£¬Ò²¾ÍûÓвÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÄܶ¯ÐÔ¡£
¡¡¡¡ÒŲú×ÊÔ´µÄ¹«¹²ÊôÐÔ¾ö¶¨ÁËËüÓ빫ÖÚȺÌåÀûÒæÆÕ±éÏà¹Ø£¬Ò²ÕýÊÇÕâÖÖÆÕ±éÏà¹ØÐÔÔÚÒ»¶¨³Ì¶ÈÉÏÖÆÔ¼Á˹«ÖڼලµÄÄܶ¯ÐÔ¡£ÔÚ¡°Ô²Ã÷԰ʼþ¡±ÖУ¬ÕâÑùÒ»ÏîÉùÊƺƴóµÄ¹¤³ÌÄܹ»Ä¬Ä¬µØ½øÐÐÁËÁ½ÄêÖ®¾Ã£¬ÓëÆä˵ÊÇÎÞÈË·¢ÏÖ£¬²»Èç˵ÊÇÎÞÈË¿ÏÌᣬ»òÎÞÈ˸ÒÌᣬֱÖÁʼþÆع⣬ÈËÃDzÅȺÆð¶ø¹¥Ö®¡£Òò´Ë£¬ÔÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ¹ý³ÌÖУ¬Õë¶Ô²»Í¬µÄ¹æ»®ÏîÄ¿¾ö²ß£¬±ß¼ÊЧÓøߵĹ«ÖÚ»áÑ¡Ôñ»ý¼«²ÎÓ룬¶ø±ß¼ÊЧÓõ͵Ĺ«ÖÚÔòÏà¶ÔÏû¼«µÃ¶à¡£
2.4 ¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆÚ
¡¡¡¡¡°Ð§Á¦¡±¾ÍÊÇÖ¸¹æ·¶(norm)µÄÌØÊâ´æÔÚ£¬ËµÒ»¸ö¹æ·¶ÓÐЧÁ¦¾ÍÊÇ˵ÎÒÃǼٶ¨ËüµÄ´æÔÚ£¬»òÕß¾ÍÊÇ˵£¬ÎÒÃǼٶ¨Ëü¶ÔÄÇЩÆäÐÐΪÓÉËüËùµ÷ÕûµÄÈ˾ßÓС°Ô¼ÊøÁ¦¡±¡£¶ø¡°²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄЧÁ¦¡±¾ÍÊÇÖ¸ÔÚ³ÇÊй滮¹ý³ÌÖУ¬¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄ¹æ·¶¶ÔÓڹ滮¾ö²ßÕßËù¾ßÓеÄÔ¼ÊøÁ¦£¬ÒÔ¼°¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄÐÐΪ¶Ô¹æ»®¾ö²ß½á¹ûËùÄܲúÉúµÄʵ¼ÊÓ°Ïì(¿¶ûÉ£¬1996)¡£
¡¡¡¡¹«ÖÚ¸öÌåÔÚ×ö³öÐÐΪ¾ö²ß֮ǰ£¬±ØȻҪÊÂÏÈÔ¤ÆÚÐÐΪ½á¹û£¬¼´Ô¤ÆÚ¸öÈ˵IJÎÓëÄܹ»¶Ô¹æ»®¾ö²ßµÄ×îÖÕ½á¹û²úÉú¶à´óµÄÓ°ÏìÁ¦¡£Èç¹ûÔ¤ÆÚЧÁ¦ºÜµÍ£¬ÈÏΪ¸Ã²ÎÓ뷽ʽֻÊÇËùνµÄÐÎʽÖ÷Ò壬²¢²»»á¶Ô¹æ»®¾ö²ß²úÉúЧÁ¦£¬ÄÇô¹«ÖھͲ»»á»ý¼«µØ²ÎÓë¹æ»®£»Èç¹û¹«ÖÚÄܹ»È·ÐÅ×Ô¼ºµÄ²ÎÓëÄܹ»ÇÐʵ·¢»ÓÖØÒª×÷Óã¬ÄÇôÆä²ÎÓëµÄ»ý¼«ÐԾͻá¸ßÕÇ¡£
¡¡¡¡¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆڵĻù´¡Êǹú¼ÒµÄ·¨ÖƱ£ÕÏ£¬Èç¹û´æÔÚÏà¹ØµÄ¹ú¼Ò·¨ÖÆ¡¢·¨¹æ£¬Äܹ»±£ÕϹ«ÖÚÔÚ³ÇÊй滮½ø³ÌÖвÎÓëµÄÄÚÈÝ¡¢³ÌÐòºÍȨÁ¦£¬ÄÇôÈÏΪ²ÎÓëÓÐЧµÄ»ý¼«Ô¤ÆÚÔò»á´ó´óÔö¼Ó£¬·´Ö®Ôò»á½µµÍ¹«ÖڵĻý¼«Ô¤ÆÚ¡£´ËÍ⣬ЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆÚ»¹Êܵ½Éç»á´ó»·¾³µÄÓ°Ï죬Èç¹ûÉç»á´ó»·¾³¹ÄÀø¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®£¬²¢ÇÒÓÐʵ¼ùÖ¤Ã÷¹«ÖÚµÄÒâ¼ûÄܹ»¶Ô×îÖյĹ滮¾ö²ß½á¹û²úÉú×÷Óã¬Ò²¿ÉÒÔ´ÓЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆڵĽǶȼ¤·¢¹«ÖڵIJÎÓëÈÈÇ飬Ìá¸ß¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®¹ý³ÌµÄÕæʵÐÔ¡£
¡¡¡¡µ±Ç°ÎÒ¹ú¹«ÖڼලµÄÖ÷Òª·½Ê½ÊÇÌýÖ¤Öƶȡ£ÌýÖ¤Öƶȵľ«ËèÊÇÓÃÒ»ÖÖÐÎʽÕýÒåÀ´È·±£ÊµÖÊÕýÒ壬ÓóÌÐò¹«Æ½À´È·±£½á¹û¹«Õý¡£Õë¶Ô¡°Ô²Ã÷԰ʼþ¡±£¬ÖÐÑëµçÊǪ́¡¶¶«·½Ê±¿Õ¡·À¸Ä¿Ôø¾¾Í¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÌýÖ¤»áµÄЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆÚ×÷ÁËÒ»´Îµ÷²é£¬ÆäÖÐÈÏΪ¡°×÷Óýϴó£¬ÌýÈ¡ÃñÒâʹ¾ö²ß¸üÃñÖ÷¡±µÄÕ¼9£¥£¬ÈÏΪ¡°Óв¿·Ö×÷Óã¬ÌåÏÖÁËÌýÈ¡ÃñÒâµÄ̬¶È¡±µÄÕ¼27£¥£¬¶øÈÏΪ¡°×÷Óò»´ó£¬ÃñÒâºÜÉÙ±»²ÉÄÉ¡±µÄ´ïµ½64£¥¡£¿É¼û£¬¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓÚ²ÎÓë¼à¶½µÄЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆÚÊǷdz£µÍµÄ£¬¶øÕâÒ²Ö±½ÓÓ°ÏìÁËÎÒ¹ú¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¼à¶½µÄÐÐΪѡÔñ¡£
3¡¢´Ù½ø¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄÏà¹Ø´ëÊ©
¡¡¡¡´ÓÎÒ¹úÄ¿Ç°Çé¿ö¿´£¬Ò»·½Ã棬¹«Öڷdz£Ï£ÍûÄܹ»Í¨¹ý²ÎÓë¹æ»®À´Î¬»¤²¢ÊµÏÖ¸öÌåÀûÒ棬±£ÕÏÆä»ù±¾È¨Ò棻ÁíÒ»·½Ã棬¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄЧÁ¦Ô¤ÆÚ¡¢¹æ»®¾ö²ß¸Ä½øºóµÄ±ß¼ÊЧÓõȲîÒìÔÚÒ»¶¨³Ì¶ÈÉÏÓÖÓ°ÏìÁ˹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄʵ¼ÊÖÊÁ¿¡£Òò´Ë£¬Á¢×ãÓÚ¹«ÖڵĽǶȣ¬ÇÐʵÌá¸ßÎÒ¹ú³ÇÊй滮ÖеĹ«ÖÚ²ÎÓë³Ì¶È£¬Ó¦µ±´ÓÒÔÏÂÈý¸ö·½ÃæÈëÊÖ¡£
3.1 ÍêÉÆ·¨ÖÆÌåϵ¡ª¼ÓÇ¿¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄ»ù´¡±£ÕÏ
¡¡¡¡·¨ÖÆÌåϵµÄÖͺóÊÇÎÒ¹ú³ÇÊй滮¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÁ÷ÓÚÐÎʽµÄÖ÷ÒªÔÒò£¬ÕâÖÖÖͺó¿Í¹ÛÉϵ¼ÖÂÁ˹«ÖÚ¶Ô²ÎÓë¹æ»®Ð§Á¦µÄÏû¼«Ô¤ÆÚ£¬²¢½øÒ»²½Ôì³ÉÁ˹«ÖÚÔڹ滮¹ý³ÌÖеÄÏû¼«²ÎÓë¡£Ë×»°Ëµ¡°ÎÞ¹æ¾Ø²»³É·½Ô²¡±£¬Ã»Óз¨ÂɵÄÇÐʵ½ç¶¨£¬¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÔÚʵ¼ùÖоͳÉΪ¡°ÎÞÍÁ֮ľ¡±£¬Òò¶ø·¨ÂÉÊÇÕþ²ßµÃÒԹ᳹ʵʩµÄÇ°ÌáºÍ±£ÕÏ¡£ÃÀ¹úµÄÕþÖξ¼Ãѧ¼Ò°¢Âס¤µÂÀ×Ôó(Allan¡¤ Drazen)ÔÚÑо¿Õþ²ß³ÐŵÓë·¨ÂÉÖ®¼äµÄ¹Øϵʱ£¬Ôø¾¾«±ÙµØÖ¸³ö£º¡°·¨ÂÉÊÇÕþ²ßµÄ±£ÕÏ£¬Ã»Óз¨ÂɵijÐŵÓëÓз¨ÂÉÖ§³ÖµÄ³Ðŵ£¬¶þÕßÖ®¼äÓкܴóµÄÇø±ð¡£Ê×ÏÈ£¬×î¸ù±¾µÄÇø±ðÊÇ·¨ÂÉÓгͷ£Ìõ¿î£¬ËùÒÔÎ¥·¨ÓÐÃ÷È·µÄ³É±¾£»Æä´Î£¬ÊÇÃ÷È·µÄ·¨ÂÉ»ò±»¹ã·º³ÐÈϵÄÉç»á¹æ·¶£¬Ê¹Î¥·¨ÐÐΪ¸üÏÔÑÛ£¬Òò´Ë´ú¼ÛÒ²¸ü¸ß¡±¡£
¡¡¡¡ÔçÔÚ1947Ä꣬Ӣ¹ú¡¶³ÇÏç¹æ»®·¨°¸¡·¾Í¹æ¶¨ÔÊÐí¹«ÖÚ¶Ô³ÇÊй滮·¢±íÒâ¼ûºÍ¿´·¨£»1969Ä꣬ÔÚ¡¶³ÇÏç¹æ»®·¨°¸¡·µÄÐÞ¶©ÖУ¬ÓÖÖƶ¨ÁËÓ봫ͳµÄ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÓÐËù²»Í¬µÄ·½·¨¡¢Í¾¾¶ºÍÐÎʽ£¬¼´ÖøÃûµÄ¡¶Ë¹¿Ë·Ò¶Ù±¨¸æ¡·(the Skeffington Report)£¬³ÉΪ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë³ÇÊй滮·¢Õ¹µÄÀï³Ì±®¡£È»¶øÔÚÎÒ¹úÄ¿Ç°µÄ³ÇÊй滮·¨¹æÖУ¬ÉÐÎÞ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®Á¢·¨µÄÄÚÈݹ涨¡£ËäÈ»ÎÒ¹úµÄ¡¶Á¢·¨·¨¡·Ê×´ÎÈ·Á¢Á˹«ÃñÔÚÁ¢·¨¹ý³ÌÖеIJÎÓëÖƶȣ¬µ«ÊÇ×ܵÄÀ´¿´£¬¡¶Á¢·¨·¨¡·¶Ô¹«Ãñ²ÎÓëÁ¢·¨¹ý³ÌÈÔȻȱ·¦³ÌÐòÐԹ涨£¬ÓÈÆäÊǶÔÊýÁ¿´ó¡¢Ó빫ÃñÇÐÉíÀûÒæ¹ØϵÃÜÇеĵط½ÐÔ·¨¹æºÍ¹æÕÂÔÚÖƶ¨¹ý³ÌÖеÄÁ¢·¨ÌýÕþÖƶÈδ×÷¹æ¶¨£¬´Ó¶øʹ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë³ÇÊй滮Á¢·¨³ÉΪһ¼þÊ®·ÖÀ§ÄѵÄÊÂÇé¡£¼´Ê¹ÎÒ¹úµÄ¡¶ÐÐÕþ·¨¡·ÖÐÌá³öÁË¡°ÐÐÕþ¹«¿ª¡±µÄÔÔò£¬µ«Ò²Ö»ÊDZ£ÕÏÁ˹«ÖÚµÄʺóÖªÇéȨ£¬¶øûÓб£ÕϹ«ÖÚµÄÊÂÇ°²ÎÓëȨ¡£Òò´Ë£¬ÔÚÐÞ¶©³ÇÊй滮·¨¹æʱ£¬Ó¦µ±Ê×ÏÈÈ·Á¢¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë³ÇÊй滮µÄ·¨ÂɵØλ¡£Ö»Óи³Ó蹫ÖÚ²ÎÓë³ÇÊй滮µÄºÏ·¨µØ룬¹«ÖÚ²ÅÄÜÕæÕýʵÏÖ¶Ô¹«¹²ÊÂÎñµÄ²ÎÓ룬ÌåÏÖ³ÇÊй滮µÄ¡°Á¢·¨Îª¹«£¬¹æ»®ÎªÃñ¡±¡£
3.2 ÐÎʽ±£ÕÏÄÚÈÝ¡ªÌá¸ß¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄ²ã¼¶½á¹¹
¡¡¡¡±ØÒªµÄÐÎʽÊDZ£ÕÏÄÚÈݵÃÒÔʵÏÖµÄÇ°Ìá¡£1969ÄêÃÀ¹ú¹æ»®Ê¦É¯Àò¡¤°¢¶û˹̹(Sherry¡¤Arnstein)ÔÚ¡¶ÊÐÃñ²ÎÓë½×ÌÝ¡·Ò»ÎÄÖУ¬´Óʵ¼ù½Ç¶ÈÌá³öÁ˹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë³ÇÊй滮³Ì¶ÈµÄ½×¶ÎÄ£ÐÍÀíÂÛ£¬¼´¡°ÊÐÃñ²ÎÓë½×ÌÝ¡±ÀíÂÛ¡£Ëý¶Ô¡°¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓ롱ÕâÒ»¸ÅÄî½øÐÐÁËϵͳµÄ·ÖÎö£¬ÈÏΪ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¿ÉÒÔ·ÖΪÈý¸ö²ã´Î°Ë¸öÌݼ¶£¬×îµÍ²ã´ÎÊÇ¡°ÎÞ²ÎÓ롱(Nonpar-ticipation)£»µÚ¶þ²ã´ÎÊÇ¡°ÏóÕ÷ÐԵIJÎÓ롱(Tokenism)£»µÚÈý²ã´ÎÊÇ¡°ÊÐÃñȨÀû¡±(Citizen Power)¡£
¡¡¡¡´ÓÄ¿Ç°µÄ²ÎÓ뷽ʽ¡¢¿ªÕ¹ÊֶΣ¬ÒÔ¼°²ÎÓë½×¶Î¿´£¬ÎÒ¹ú³ÇÊй滮ÖеĹ«ÖÚÉд¦ÓÚÒ»ÖÖ¡°±»¶¯Ê½¡±µÄ¹ý³Ì²ÎÓ룬¶ø²»ÊÇÕæÕýÒâÒåÉϵÄÖ÷¶¯ÐÔ¾ö²ß²ÎÓ룬»¹Í£ÁôÔÚ¡°ÏóÕ÷ÐÔ²ÎÓ롱½×¶Î£¬Æ京ÓÐÈý¸öÌݼ¶£º»ñϤ(Informing)¡¢×Éѯ(Consultation)¡¢ÁÐϯ(Placation)¡£ÕâÖÖ±»¶¯µÄ²ÎÓëÐÎʽΥ±³Á˹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄ±¾ÖÊ£¬ÕýÈçɯÀò¡¤°¢¶û˹̹ËùÖ¸³öµÄÄÇÑù£º¡°¿Õ¶´µÄ¡¢ÒÇʽÐԵIJÎÓëͬӵÓÐÕæÕýȨÁ¦µÄ¡¢Äܹ»Ó°Ïì×îÖÕ½á¹ûµÄ²ÎÓ룬¶þÕßÖ®¼ä´æÔÚ×ű¾ÖÊÇø±ð¡£¡±
¡¡¡¡ËùÒÔ£¬ÒªÕæÕýʵÏÖ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÓɱ»¶¯×ßÏòÖ÷¶¯£¬¾ÍÓ¦µ±ÔÊÐí¹«ÖÚ½éÈë³ÇÊй滮µÄÇ°ÆÚ¾ö²ß½×¶Î£¬Êèͨ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ¡°ºôÓõ¡±ÇþµÀ£¬Ìá¸ß¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ²ã´Î£¬¸Ä±äÓɹ滮¹ÜÀí²¿Ãŵ¥ÏòµØ¶Ô¹«ÖÚչʾ¹æ»®½á¹ûµÄ¾ÖÃ棬½¨Á¢°üº¬¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄË«Ïò·´À¡Ñ»·»úÖÆ¡£µ±È»£¬ÎÒ¹ú¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®²ã´ÎµÄÌá¸ßÒ²ÐèÒªÒ»¸ö½¥½øµÄ¹ý³Ì£¬ÓÐЩѧÕß½è¼ø¹úÍâµÄ¾ÑéÌá³öÁËÎÒ¹ú¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄ¡°Éú³¤Ä£Ê½¡±£¬Ò²±íÃ÷ÁËÕâÒ»»ù±¾¹Ûµã(³ÂÖ¾³ÏµÈ£¬2003)¡£
3.3 ÖҳϸеÄÅàÓý¡ª½¨Á¢¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄ·ÇÀíÐÔÓÐЧԼÊø
¡¡¡¡¡°ºôÓõ¡±µÃÒÔ·¢»Ó×÷ÓõÄÏȾöÌõ¼þÓÐÁ½¸ö£¬Ò»¸öÊÇ·¨ÖƱ£ÕÏ£¬Ò»¸öÊÇÍ˳öÍþв¡£ÓÉÓÚÎÒ¹úÏֽ׶εijÇÊй滮Ö÷Òª»¹ÊDZ»×÷ΪһÖÖÐÐÕþÖ°ÄÜÔÚ¾¼ÃÉç»áÉú»îÖÐÓèÒԹ᳹ʵʩ£¬Ï൱ÓÚ´¦ÔÚÒ»ÖÖÍêȫ¢¶ÏµÄÊг¡½á¹¹ÖУ¬¹«ÖÚÒòÎÞ·¨»ñµÃÌæ´úÆ·¶øÍ˳öÎÞÃÅ¡£Òò´Ë£¬ÓÉÓÚ×éÖ¯(Õþ¸®¹æ»®¹ÜÀí²¿ÃÅ)ûÓоºÕù¶ÔÊÖ£¬(¹«ÖÚ)Í˳ö¶ÔÓÚ×éÖ¯¶øÑÔ±ãʧȥÁËÍþв×÷Óã¬ÓÚÊǺôÓõ±ã»áÁ÷ÓÚÐÎʽ£¬Ôì³É¹æ»®¾ö²ßÕߺöÊÓ¹«ÖڵĴæÔÚ¼°Æä²ÎÓ룬ͬʱҲʹ¹«ÖÚ¶Ô²ÎÓë¹æ»®µÄЧÁ¦²úÉúÏû¼«Ô¤ÆÚ£¬ÈÝÒ×ʧȥ²ÎÓëµÄ»ý¼«ÐÔ¡£
¡¡¡¡Õë¶ÔÕâÒ»ÎÊÌ⣬ºÕÏ£ÂüÔÚ¡°Í˳ö¡ªºôÓõ¡±ÀíÂÛÖУ¬Ìá³öÁË¡°ÖÒ³Ï(Loyalty)¡±µÄ¸ÅÄî¡£ºÕÏ£ÂüµÄÂÛÖ¤¹ý³Ì±íÃ÷£¬ÖÒ³ÏÔÚÍ˳öÓëºôÓõ×éºÏ¼°Æä½»»¥×÷ÓõĹý³ÌÖУ¬°çÑÝ×ÅÒ»¸ö²»¿É»òȱµÄ½ÇÉ«¡£ÖҳϸÐÊÇÒ»ÖÖ·ÇÀíÐÔÔ¼Êø£¬Äܹ»ÔÚ¸öÌåÀíÐÔÅжÏÓ¦µ±²»×÷ΪµÄÇé¿öÏ´Ùʹ¹«ÖÚʼÖÕ±£³ÖןôÓõµÄ¼¤ÇéºÍ¼á³ÖÐÅÄî¡£´Ó³ÇÊй滮µÄ½Ç¶È½²£¬ËäÈ»ÎÒ¹úÏÖÓеĹ«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÖƶȻ¹´æÔÚÖî¶àÎÊÌ⣬µ«¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÓÚ¹ú¼Ò¡¢³ÇÊкÍÉçÇøµÄÖҳϸÐÒ²Äܹ»»½ÆðËûÃÇÇ¿ÁҵIJÎÓëÒâʶ£¬³ÉΪ¡°Ïû¼«²ÎÓ롱Óë¡°»ý¼«²ÎÓ롱µÄÈ󻬼Á£¬ÔÚÒ»¶¨³Ì¶ÈÉϾÀÕý³ÇÊй滮Öй«ÖÚ²ÎÓëµÄ±íÏó·±ÈÙÓëÄÚÔÚÙúÈõÖ®¼äµÄʧºâ¡£
¡¡¡¡µ±Ç°ÎÒ¹úµÄ¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓ뻹ͣÁôÔÚȫƾ¹«ÖÚÐËȤµÄ²ÎÓë½×¶Î£¬¶ø²»ÊÇƾ¹«ÖÚÔðÈθеIJÎÓë½×¶Î£¬Òò´Ë£¬¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓëÊ®·ÖÐèÒª¶ÔÕâÖÖÖҳϸеÄÅàÓý¡£Îª´Ë£¬Õþ¸®Ó¦µ±²ÉÈ¡Éç»á½ÌÓý¡¢Ã½ÌåÐû´«µÈ´ëÊ©ÅàÑø¹«ÖÚµÄÖ÷ÈËÎ̵Ø룬´ÙʹÆäÔÚ³ÇÊй滮²ÎÓëÖÐʵÏÖ½Çɫת»»¡ªÓɱ»¶¯µÄ½ÓÊÜÕß±äΪÖ÷¶¯µÄ²ÎÓëÕß¡£´ËÍ⣬¶Ô¼¯Ì幫ÒæµÄ¹Ø×¢Ò²ÊÇÒÔ¹«ÖÚ¶ÔÆä¸öÈËȨÀûÒâʶµÄ¾õÐÑΪÆðµãµÄ£¬¹«ÖÚ¸öÌåÒ²Ó¦µ±²»¶ÏÌá¸ß×ÔÉíµÄÐÞÑøÓëѧʶ£¬Ìá¸ß¶Ô¹«¹²ÊÂÎñµÄ¹Ø×¢³Ì¶ÈºÍ¶Ô¹«¹²¾ö²ßµÄÅжÏÄÜÁ¦¡£
[²Î¿¼ÎÄÏ×]
[1]Sherry Arnstein£®A Ladder of Citizen Participa-tion[M]£®The City Reader£¬Routledge Press£¬1996¡£
[2]°¢¶û²®ÌØ¡¤O¡¤ºÕÏ£ÂüÖø£¬Â¬²ý³çÒ룮Í˳ö¡¢ºôÓõÓëÖҳϡª¶ÔÆóÒµ¡¢×éÖ¯ºÍ¹ú¼ÒË¥Í˵ĻØÓ¦[M]£®±±¾©£º¾¼Ã¿Æѧ³ö°æÉ磬2002¡£
[3]°¢Âס¤µÂÀ×ÔóÖø£¬¶ÅÁ½Ê¡£¬Ê·ÓÀ¶«Ò룮ºê¹Û¾¼ÃѧÖеÄÕþÖξ¼Ãѧ[M]£®±±¾©£º¾¼Ã¿Æѧ³ö°æÉ磬2003¡£
[4]³ÂÖ¾³Ï£¬²ÜÈÙÁÖ£¬ÖìÐËƽ£®¹úÍâ³ÇÊй滮¹«ÖÚ²ÎÓë¼°½è¼ø[J]£®³ÇÊÐÎÊÌ⣬2003£¬(5)¡£
[5]¹ù¡¡½¨£¬Ëï»ÝÁ«£®³ÇÊй滮Öй«¹²²ÎÓëµÄ·¨Ñ§Ë¼¿¼[J]£®³ÇÊй滮£¬2004£¬(1)¡£
[6]¿¶ûÉ£®·¨Óë¹ú¼ÒµÄÒ»°ãÀíÂÛ[M]£®±±¾©£ºÖйú´ó°Ù¿ÆÈ«Êé³ö°æÉ磬1996¡£
[7]ÕÅÏþÑ࣮³ÇÊй滮Ó빫ÖÚ²ÎÓë[J]£®Ð²ο¼£¬2003£¬(11)¡£
×÷Õß¼ò½é£º
ÎâÈËΤ,ÄÐ,ͬ¼Ã´óѧ½¨ÖþÓë³ÇÊй滮ѧԺ·ç¾°ÂÃÓÎϵ½ÌÊÚ,²©Ê¿Éúµ¼Ê¦.
Ñî¼Ì÷,Å®,ͬ¼Ã´óѧ½¨ÖþÓë³ÇÊй滮ѧԺ·ç¾°ÂÃÓÎϵ2004¼¶²©Ê¿Ñо¿Éú.